What Does it Mean to Be a Lukewarm Church?

Church and MinistryEcclesiology
What Does it Mean to Be a Lukewarm Church?

Among the idioms familiar in Christianese is the phrase, “They’re on fire for the Lord.” In High School, an on-fire Christian was someone totally committed to following Jesus. There was a youth conference back in those days called Acquire the Fire, and its goal was to ignite young believers through exuberant worship and motivational messages. I remember leaving enflamed a time or two—the only trouble was that the fire never seemed to last. A few weeks after the spiritual high, feelings would already begin to wane. Fortunately, you could always acquire the fire during next year’s conference—at least until the whole operation dissolved in 2015.

When Jesus spoke to the church in Laodicea, he accused them of being lukewarm. Perhaps it’s our Christianese that has added to the confusion concerning what exactly he meant. I always read the text as Jesus coming to the believers in Laodicea and saying, “You’re not on fire for me anymore!” You know, their devotional life was inconsistent and their worship lacked vigor. This tepid spirituality was offensive to Jesus, so he was going to spit them out. In this schema, being hot (on fire) for Jesus is good, lukewarm is bad, and cold is real bad.

But a closer reading of the text doesn’t allow for this kind of interpretation. Would that you were either cold or hot!” Jesus said (Rev. 3:15b). A chilled believer is just as pleasing to Jesus as a scorching saint. The problem is lukewarmness.

Lukewarm: Worthless and Inhospitable

Many recent commentators have appealed to a historical problem to illuminate this text: the Laodicean water supply. Situated just north of Laodicea were the hot springs of Hierapolis. Apparently, that area is still known for its thermal springs believed to have healing properties. Southeast of Laodicea you had the cold waters of Colossae which flowed down from Mt. Cadmus, perfect for a refreshing drink. But by the time the hot Hierapolian and the cold Colossian waters reached Laodicea, they had lost their coveted temperatures. The salt was flavorless, if you will. The waters were unable to heal or refresh.

Here, to be lukewarm is to be worthless. Perhaps the Laodiceans had so compromised their faith by capitulating to the surrounding paganism that their witness had become ineffective. While the historical background lends itself to this understanding (and there’s internal evidence the Laodiceans were indeed getting cozy with the pagan culture) there’s another interpretation that I think warrants our attention: to be lukewarm is to be inhospitable to Jesus.

In the ancient world, hospitality was a big deal. The way you treated your guest could bring you great honor or shame. In the foreground of the passage is the picture of table fellowship with Jesus: “Behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him, and he with me” (Rev. 3:20).

Strange that Jesus is on the doorstep of this church, isn’t it? We expect him around the table, but something is awry. The Laodicean church was inhospitable to the church’s head. Instead of cold water on a hot day, they offered him lukewarm pride. And God resists the proud by spitting them out. Note verse 17, “For you say, I am rich, I have prospered, and I need nothing, not realizing that you are wretched, pitiable, poor, blind, and naked.” This isn’t a waned devotional life, it’s arrogant self-sufficiency that manifests itself in total spiritual blindness. The Laodiceans had started to think they simply didn’t need Jesus.

“Come, buy, and eat!”

Have you ever had a salesperson show up to your door and knock, and you pretended like you weren’t home? Sometimes we don’t answer the door because we have no interest in what’s for sale. Christ has something to sell us, but if we don’t think we need it, we’ll happily carry on around our Christless table. “I counsel you to buy from me gold refined by fire, so that you may be rich, and white garments so that you may clothe yourself, and the shame of your nakedness may not be seen, and salve to anoint your eyes, so that you may see” (Rev. 3:18). No doubt Jesus’s rebuke of the Laodiceans is a strong one, but it’s issued in fatherly love (Rev. 3:19). The imagery of knocking at the door is probably taken from Song of Songs 5:2, where the lover is seeking intimacy with his beloved. Christ comes to this arrogant church as a concerned father and a jealous husband. He invites the lukewarm to buy what they need from him.

How do you buy gold, white garments, and eye salve from Jesus? You can’t—at least not with cash or credit. The language here reminds us of Isaiah 55:1, “Come, everyone who thirsts, come to the waters; and he who has no money, come, buy, and eat! Come, buy wine and milk without money and without price.” What we desperately need, Jesus freely gives.

The book of Revelation ends with an invitation, “Let the one who is thirsty come; let the one who desires take the water of life without price” (Rev. 22:17b). The Laodiceans had lukewarm waters because Jesus wasn’t at the table. He brings—and is himself—the main course of the feast, providing the ice-cold waters of salvation. Churches that proudly rely on their own wealth or wisdom may find that like the Laodiceans, they’re eating alone. To them, Jesus comes knocking.

Adriel Sanchez is the pastor of North Park Presbyterian Church (PCA) in San Diego, CA. He received his theological training from Westminster Seminary California and serves as host of Core Christianity. Adriel is the author of Praying with Jesus and, most recently, Why We Worship: Experiencing Heaven on Earth at Church. He and his wife, Ysabel, have six children.

Sola Newspaper

Today's Offer

Sola Newspaper

A quarterly print publication featuring articles on theology, the confessions, & reflections for the Christian life, delivered straight to your mailbox. For free.

Subscribe Now

More on this topic

Church and Ministry

Explore All

Vocation: God Doesn’t Need Your Good Works, but Your Neighbor Does

Scott Keith from ‪1517.org‬ joins Michael Horton, Bob Hiller, Walter Strickland, and Justin Holcomb to discuss how churches can recover high views of preaching and the sacraments, as well as robust views and practices around vocation.

5 Signs Your Church Might Be Too Seeker-Sensitive

Is it wrong for a church to be seeker sensitive? Pastor Adriel Sanchez expounds on the differences between seeker-sensitive and seeker-driven churches, and why ordering our services to be palatable for certain demographics is a way of domesticating the worship of God.

A Presbyterian and Lutheran on What Most Christians Miss About Church

A Presbyterian and Lutheran on What Most Christians Miss About Church

Episode 1582 | According to Pew Research, only 51% of self-identified Christians attend church regularly. Pastor Adriel Sanchez is joined by Caleb Keith from ‪1517 where they both argue that this crisis is not primarily cultural, but theological. Most Christians are simply unaware what the church actually is, what happens there, and why nothing else can replace it.

A mother and daughter sitting together in a church pew.

When Mother’s Day Misfires

I’ve rolled into church many a Mother’s Day morning with a heavy heart and deflated expectations. There were years of singleness, and then miscarriage, when I felt invisible in the pew, wondering if I would ever wear the title of “mother” myself. Then came holidays where I felt steamrolled by the demands of raising babies […]

Help more people know what they believe and why.

Support trusted articles, podcasts, and resources that deepen faith, point people to Christ, and strengthen the church.

Give Monthly