How Many of the Ten Commandments Do Americans Think They’ve Broken This Month?

MoralityPolitics
How Many of the Ten Commandments Do Americans Think They’ve Broken This Month?

In the “Fast Money” segment that concluded this particular Family Feud episode, two members of the winning family were each asked to guess the responses to five questions posed to 100 surveyed people. The very first question: How many of the ten commandments have you broken this month?

When the first contestant Lyndsey answers, “Three,” host Steve Harvey and the audience chuckle (0:25 mark in the video below). Then when the second contestant Lauren answers, “Seven,” Steve Harvey is shocked into silence (2:10) while the audience again laughs. But when the number of responses for “Seven” is later revealed, Harvey lets loose with incredulous laughter (2:35 forward). “Seven out of ten?,” Harvey asks, “Who does that?” The answer? Evidently zero. No one.

We’re told the most frequent response to the question was “One.” It’s perhaps telling: People may admit they sin, but just a little—one-out-of-ten-commandments-this-month little. We’re sinners, but not YUGE sinners! Or some people may not see themselves as sinning at all: This Family Feud exchange really makes me wonder how many of the one-hundred surveyed answered “Zero” or “None.” (By the way, when these “Fast Money” questions ask for a number, the question is usually prefaced with “On a scale from 1 to 10,” so the respondents might have been preconditioned to avoid saying zero/none.) Surely some of the one-hundred answered Zero or None.

Regardless—one or none—this view of self is far removed from the understanding of sin expressed in James 2:10. Let’s quote the Good News Translation, as it seems suitable for the “Good answer, good answer” sensibility of the show:

“Whoever breaks one commandment is guilty of breaking them all.” (James 2:10 GNT)

Furthermore, this view of sin and self is far from understanding Jesus’ own Sermon on the Mount teaching on the nature of the moral law (“whoever is angry with his brother…” and so on). And it necessarily represents a view that must also vastly underestimate the offensiveness of any and all sin to God. It surely fails to appreciate just how great the price Christ paid on the cross to make propitiation for our sins. Seven? Chuckle-chuckle, ha-ha.

Imagine the shock had either of the contestants answered, “Ten”—and then responded to Steve Harvey’s by reciting James 2:10! Or imagine if the Number One answer had been “Ten”—and no one was shocked!

It must be the aim of our Great Commission efforts to share with others the breadth and depth of our Family Feud with God. For as Martin Luther explained, “The recognition of sin is the beginning of salvation.” And in the end, the Good News is the only Good Answer.

James H. Gilmore is author of Look: A Practical Guide for Improving Your Observational Skills, The Experience Economy, and Authenticity: What Consumers Really Want, as well as a visiting lecturer in apologetics at Westminster Seminary California.

Sola Newspaper

Today's Offer

Sola Newspaper

A quarterly print publication featuring articles on theology, the confessions, & reflections for the Christian life, delivered straight to your mailbox. For free.

Subscribe Now

More on this topic

Morality

Explore All

How Should Believers Respond to Claims About ‘AI Welfare’?

In a humorous moment in the movie Fiddler on the Roof, the main character, Tevye, looks into the camera and remarks, “You may ask, how did this tradition get started? I’ll tell you—I don’t know! But it’s a tradition.” This sets the scene for the movie’s story of Tevye adapting to the changing world around him […]

Reacting to Viral Dechurching & Exvangelical Stories

Reacting to Viral Dechurching & Exvangelical Stories

“Here’s what I love about Jesus. Jesus actually knows that the church is broken and imperfect and falls short. But the difference between us and Jesus is we see that and we use that as a justification to abandon the church. Jesus sees the church, as broken as she is, and on the way as […]

Is the Bible Pro Slavery?

Is the Bible Pro Slavery?

Throughout history, people have appealed to the Bible’s teaching on slavery to justify their own practices. So is the Bible pro slavery? And what’s the difference between biblical slavery and the American slavery of the not so distant past?

Was Slavery in the Bible the Same as American Slavery?

Was Slavery in the Bible the Same as American Slavery?

Despite the fact that God allowed for slavery, embedded in the Scripture is a sobering rebuke of the institution, as well as an anthropology that teaches that all people are made in God’s image. So the objectification of an image bearer, seeing them as nothing more than an object or property that you can abuse, […]

Help more people know what they believe and why.

Support trusted articles, podcasts, and resources that deepen faith, point people to Christ, and strengthen the church.

Give Monthly