Help! My Mentor Has Left the Faith!

Repentance
open wide book on desk

“Order whatever you want,” I told my friend from my high school years. We were at Red Robin, and I didn’t have much money, but I knew I had more than this single mom, whom I had shared the gospel with a few years before. I watched as she stuffed herself with food she didn’t need to pay for. And she told me her story.

“Do you remember our friend, Mary? She talked to me about Jesus long before and long after you came and went. Well, she no longer follows Jesus.” I knew this—I had been at a reunion of old friends and saw how far Mary had walked away. “So what do I do now? I am struggling—obviously—but the person who told me about Jesus no longer believes in Jesus. What do I do?”

Friends, you may be in the same place as my friend was. Let me offer you a few encouragements if your mentor has left the faith.

First, it is natural to feel unbalanced and uncertain. Maybe you think to yourself, “There was nothing that made her faith more or less sincere than my own.” It is important that we don’t dress up our insecurities and provide answers the Lord has not provided. We need to bring our honest struggles to a God who has promised to help. We can pray to him, “I believe, help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24)

Second, our God loves to use broken vessels to save us. The Lord has graciously used me to help others to know and follow Jesus, and I am embarrassed almost every time I see these brothers and sisters afterward because of my own unending struggle with sin. I forget that it is the Lord who rescued these sinners, not me (1 Tim. 1:15–17). We should not glory in the instruments the Lord uses, but in the fact that God strikes straight blows with crooked sticks, as an old theologian would say.

Third, our faith has a resting place: Jesus. Every day, people rise and people fall; Christians prevail and Christians fail. Jesus does not fail. The apostle Paul rebuked Peter, who had believed and followed Jesus years before Paul (Gal. 2:11–14). He could do so because his faith did not rely upon Peter, but upon Jesus—who is the author of our faith and perfects it (Heb. 12:2).

No one had a greater opportunity to fail than Jesus. He was prepared to drink the cup of God’s wrath. Satan sought to deter him. His disciples slept rather than prayed with him. Yet, Jesus declared “your will be done” (Matt. 26:42). He did not fail the frail people who depended upon him, and he will not fail you.

Friends, I am sorry that your mentors failed you. My heart has been broken by those I trusted as well. But do you know who will not break your heart, but will instead hold and uphold it? Your lord and savior, Jesus Christ. He does not slumber or sleep. He will keep you both now and forevermore (Ps. 121).

If our faith rests upon those the Lord uses, we are doomed. If it rests upon the savior who lived the life we couldn’t live, and died the death we couldn’t bear, then our hope is imperishable. Rest in your savior, so that if or when your mentor fails, you can continue to “run with endurance the race that is set before us” (Heb. 12:1), looking only to him who purchased you by his own blood.

Stephen Roberts (D.Min. at Birmingham Theological Seminary) is an Army chaplain and also writes for Modern Reformation and has written for numerous other publications. He is married to Lindsey—a journalist—and they have three delightful and precocious children.

Sola Newspaper

Today's Offer

Sola Newspaper

A quarterly print publication featuring articles on theology, the confessions, & reflections for the Christian life, delivered straight to your mailbox. For free.

Subscribe Now

More on this topic

Repentance

Explore All
Assurance in the Shadow of Doubt

Assurance in the Shadow of Doubt

The coexistence of assurance and doubt is not a contradiction, but a reflection of the Christian life lived between justification and glorification. True assurance rests not in the strength of one’s faith, but in the object of that faith—Jesus Christ—and the presence of doubt, while unsettling, does not nullify genuine belief.

Our Victory Is Between the Flags of Sound Doctrine

Our Victory Is Between the Flags of Sound Doctrine

Following sound doctrine requires our eyes to remain fixed on Jesus. It also requires that our faith rests in him. Faith opens the door to God’s plan and allows us to accomplish his will for our lives. It does so chiefly because it fosters a heart that yields to the counsel and leading of God. In this way, we remain on the road of truth.

Walking by Faith Isn't Wishful Thinking

Walking by Faith Isn’t Wishful Thinking

We are not merely hoping for the best outcome, we are assured of the greatest outcome—the coming of God’s Kingdom. Our faith doesn’t work like a magic eight ball, trying to tell us every detail of our lives, but our faith is knowledgeable.

A lush garden in Israel bordered by a wall with trees behind it.

Why Did Jesus Say “Don’t Cling to Me?”

Jesus’s words were a puzzle to me for a long time. Why would he push Mary away in her moment of joyful recognition? According to his own words, it seems he has some unfinished business: “I have not yet ascended to the Father” is how Jesus tells Mary—and us—that his ascension is absolutely necessary for his redeeming purposes to be brought to completion.

Help more people know what they believe and why.

Support trusted articles, podcasts, and resources that deepen faith, point people to Christ, and strengthen the church.

Give Monthly