FAQ: Christians Should Go to Church—But Is Everyone in the Church a Christian?

Church and MinistryEcclesiology
FAQ: Christians Should Go to Church—But Is Everyone in the Church a Christian?

Does going to church make you a Christian? Is showing up on Sunday and sitting in a pew what makes you a disciple of Jesus?

No. Just going to church on a Sunday morning doesn’t mean that you have a vital relationship with Jesus Christ as your personal Savior. Sadly, there are many people who are in churches, maybe who even grew up in churches, who don’t understand and embrace the gospel. Maybe for some, going to church is just a tradition. Maybe it’s a way of feeling good about themselves. But they’ve never really understood the message of salvation.

Just going into a church to pray or to visit or even spending one’s entire life in a church doesn’t make someone a Christian. If you don’t believe in Jesus and receive the gospel by faith, then it doesn’t matter where you are on Sunday morning.

One of the books in the New Testament that addresses this is Hebrews. The author of Hebrews is writing to people who were in church. They had experienced the rituals of the church—baptism and probably the Lord’s Supper— but they were beginning to drift away from Christ. He’s worried that like Israel in the wilderness, they’ll fail to reach the promised land—which for Christians is eternal joy and rest in God’s presence. So, the writer is really concerned for their souls. In Hebrews 4:1, he says, “Therefore, while the promise of entering his rest still stands, let us fear lest any of you should seem to have failed to reach it. For the good news came to us just as to them (Israel).”

What if these people had been in the church all that time, but—like Israel in the wilderness—had never really believed the gospel message?

Do you know what the gospel is? It’s the fact that we were sinners and couldn’t earn God’s grace, mercy, love, or forgiveness, and yet he sent his Son Jesus into the world so that we might have life through his death and resurrection from the dead and our sins would be forgiven.

Do you believe that? Have you received that message? Have you placed your trust in Jesus? If you have, you’re a Christian.

And if you’re a Christian, you should be in a church. That’s because when we’re united to Jesus by faith, he unites us to the church—his people.

Christians should be in churches, but just because you’re in a church doesn’t mean that you’ve really received the gospel. It doesn’t necessarily mean that you believe in Jesus. And so we have to ask ourselves, do I believe in Christ? Am I trusting in him? And if I am, am I in a local church, which is the community Christ calls me to join?

This article is part of our Frequently Asked Questions series. Listen to Pastor Adriel answer this question on Core Radio here.

Dig deeper with these free resources from Core Christianity:

Core Questions

These clear and concise PDFs answer some of your toughest questions about the Christian faith:
Do I Have to Attend Church to Be a Christian?
How Do I Choose a Church?

Core Guides

Dive deeper with these lengthier and more thorough guides to difficult topics in the Christian life:
9 Ways to Know You Are Really a Christian
8 Things Everyone Should Know about the Church

Adriel Sanchez is the pastor of North Park Presbyterian Church (PCA) in San Diego, CA. He received his theological training from Westminster Seminary California and serves as host of Core Christianity. Adriel is the author of Praying with Jesus and, most recently, Why We Worship: Experiencing Heaven on Earth at Church. He and his wife, Ysabel, have six children.

Sola Newspaper

Today's Offer

Sola Newspaper

A quarterly print publication featuring articles on theology, the confessions, & reflections for the Christian life, delivered straight to your mailbox. For free.

Subscribe Now

More on this topic

Church and Ministry

Explore All

Vocation: God Doesn’t Need Your Good Works, but Your Neighbor Does

Scott Keith from ‪1517.org‬ joins Michael Horton, Bob Hiller, Walter Strickland, and Justin Holcomb to discuss how churches can recover high views of preaching and the sacraments, as well as robust views and practices around vocation.

5 Signs Your Church Might Be Too Seeker-Sensitive

Is it wrong for a church to be seeker sensitive? Pastor Adriel Sanchez expounds on the differences between seeker-sensitive and seeker-driven churches, and why ordering our services to be palatable for certain demographics is a way of domesticating the worship of God.

A Presbyterian and Lutheran on What Most Christians Miss About Church

A Presbyterian and Lutheran on What Most Christians Miss About Church

Episode 1582 | According to Pew Research, only 51% of self-identified Christians attend church regularly. Pastor Adriel Sanchez is joined by Caleb Keith from ‪1517 where they both argue that this crisis is not primarily cultural, but theological. Most Christians are simply unaware what the church actually is, what happens there, and why nothing else can replace it.

A mother and daughter sitting together in a church pew.

When Mother’s Day Misfires

I’ve rolled into church many a Mother’s Day morning with a heavy heart and deflated expectations. There were years of singleness, and then miscarriage, when I felt invisible in the pew, wondering if I would ever wear the title of “mother” myself. Then came holidays where I felt steamrolled by the demands of raising babies […]

Help more people know what they believe and why.

Support trusted articles, podcasts, and resources that deepen faith, point people to Christ, and strengthen the church.

Give Monthly